Skip to main content

Inclusivity: The magic is in the other being present

Teaching teaches you as nothing else can.  I remember, as an academic exercise, watching a documentary film on transgender with students, to help understanding and acceptance. As the film progressed, in the unlit room, I could hear sounds of people shifting in their chairs in discomfort, hushed comments, giggles, and at times, loud ridicule. After the film, in the lit room, it was time for discussion. Conversations oscillated from utter indifference to absolute disapproval. The writing on the wall was loud and clear transgender people are a scandal. In the same year, we had the privilege of a couple of transgender friends come over to the campus for interaction. After the initial introduction, as a discussion starter the students along with our guests watched the same film on transgender. With the past experience, my ears and senses were tuned in for sounds of discomfort and comments of ridicule, but I heard none. I ran my eyes across the unlit room; to my disbelief there was profound silence and attentive listening. After the lights came on, the floor was open for discussion. The questions were more genuine this time; the answers found better reception and acceptance. For the students, those were moments of rebirth of their individual and collective conscience. I don't mean that the students lived happily ever after; but they lived respectfully, and were more sensitive and conscious ever after, at least they make an effort to do so.

Inclusivity
Inclusivity

Though I did not have the misfortune of studying in one, I have heard of, and these days we hear more of, exclusive schools for the poor, for the rich, for Christians for  Hindus, for Muslims. Rich kids are picked up from home to campus, and dropped back from campus to their homes. They grow up seeing the same colours, hearing the same stories and songs, thinking the same thoughts, dreaming of the same future, yet completely unaware that in the next campus there are other students growing up seeing another colour, hearing another story and song, thinking other thoughts, dreaming another future, yet who are completely unaware of the existence of the other campus. Such campuses have been on the rise. Whatever may be the reasons why adults opt for exclusive schools, reasons ranging from preserving one’s purity and standard to economic gains, it is simply disastrous for our kids, and detrimental to our society and country to educate our children without them having the possibilities of meeting others. We build parallel worlds and grumble about them not meeting. We grow brambles and expect grapes from them.

The way to inclusivity is by creating the possibility of having others (no matter who they are) with us, at least when they are the focus of our discussion. This is true of gender, ethnicity, religion, and abilities and disabilities. The magic is in the other being present. It is astonishing to watch how the presence of the other changes our thought process. A non-inclusive attempt at inclusivity is not only futile but a mockery of our shared humanity and inclusivity. Leaders of a country, a society, or an organisation, who do not indiscriminately include people of all sections into their dreaming, imagining, thinking, planning and execution,  are set to be narrow-minded, offensive and abusive.

Watch our emotions, our words

What sensations surge  in our bodies when we think about the differing other? What words crowd our conversations when we talk about them? Erstwhile ago, with the onslaught of Covid-19, India faced an unprecedented humanitarian crisis. The migrant labourers, who were the backbone of the construction of our cities’ infrastructure and economic growth, became mere migrants. They became refugees in their own country. In the words of an Afghan refugee in Australia, a refugee is resilient, is a boundary pusher, hard worker, explorer, someone who is ready to do everything for the sake of his children and his family. On a sudden everyone, yes, even establishments,  started labelling them as problematic , categorising them as illegal, unauthorised and even more. We ought to be watchful of our emotions and vocabulary with regard to the other genders, the spectrum of sexual orientations, ethnic communities, caste and class. 

Anything new and different is seen as a threat, not because of what they are but because of what we have, or what we don't have. When the celebrated Baroque art arrived on the shores England in the 17th century, Waldemar Januszczak, an art critic and television documentary producer and presenter, quoted their reaction in order to expose the resistance and ignorance of England, “there is no welcome on this shore for the sinful, the idolatrous, and the abominable… by which they meant art”. Watch our emotions, watch our words; they control our actions.

Change changes us

Homes are changing. Our children are different; they are so very unfamiliar to us. Or perhaps they always were, but we never wanted to see the differences; we were ashamed of and even held in contempt of things that were unfamiliar to us. Arundhati Roy, in her book, The Ministry Of Utmost Happiness, pens down the story of how a perspective change happened to Jahanara Begum. She and her husband were expecting their fourth child, and were desiring a boy because all three earlier children were girls. Finally the day came. In the lamp-lit night the midwife announced the good news of the birth of a boy child. That was the happiest night in Jahanara Begum’s life. They even named him as was planned long ago, Aftab. The next morning when the sun was up and the room was warm, she unswaddled little Aftab. She inspected his tiny body starting from the head - eyes, nose, head, neck, and downward. That was when she discovered that underneath his boy-parts, there was also a girl-part. He was a Hijra. Jahanara Begum froze reacting with a surge of reactions. The walls of her world came crumbling  down. The idea of what was normal and inclusive in her world took a beating. She now had to reimagine a novel a new normal and was forced to push back the boundaries of inclusivity. She was coming to terms with the fact that not everything is either man or woman.

Perhaps there was a time, when inclusivity was not our concern. We could always look the other way, but now that the unfamiliar is rightfully moving within our houses, we are sinking head-deep into it. And we have no alternative but to a leap in the dark into inclusivity. Just take the leap and swim into inclusivity. The waters are warm and heartening. The D-day of inclusivity will happen to us. We should not wait for that day but make peace with it when it is still far off, or we will be prisoners of our own non-inclusivity. 

Perhaps, for most of us, the silent, favoured lot, non-inclusivity appears to be a distant reality. Take a hint from the post-Nazi, post-war confession of Martin Niemöller “First they came for the communists/socialists, and I did not speak out, because I was not a communist/socialist. Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out, because I was not a trade unionist. Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out, because I was not a Jew. Then they came for me; and there was no one left to speak”. We see the impending future; and it is evidently approaching us. Our inclusion or our exclusion tomorrow is a choice we make today. Here is a prophecy, we will be destined to live in the prejudice and intolerance we fabricate, we will be condemned to dance on the stage we construct. We will live to the day we see the world that we fashioned collapsing on us. Yes. Any fool can be a prophet when we live in such well-defined times.

(This article is originally published in Together magazine, October 2020.)

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Visual Analysis: SEMIOTICS

 Visual analysis is a systematic and scientific approach to examining visual materials that goes far beyond casual observation.  In our visually saturated world, images have become a inescapable universal language that shapes our perceptions, attitudes, and experiences. From the artworks adorning gallery walls to the advertisements lining city streets, visuals communicate narratives, evoke emotions, and reflect sociocultural ideologies. However, the process of seeing and interpreting visuals is not as spontaneous or natural as we often assume. As John Berger notably stated, "seeing is an active decision," suggesting that the process of interpreting visuals is neither spontaneous nor natural, but rather requires conscious effort and critical thinking. The way we perceive and interpret visual content is heavily influenced by habits, conventions, and our individual perspectives.  Serious visual analyses requires conscious effort and critical analysis to unravel the laye...

Mass Media: Platforms and Content

 Mass Media today is interplay between technological infrastructure and creative expressions. Mass media, defined as channels of communication designed to reach large audiences, has undergone profound transformation in recent decades. What began as predominantly print-based communication has expanded into a multifaceted ecosystem encompassing visual, audio, and interactive modes of engagement. This essay explores the dialectical relationship between media platforms and content, arguing that the two elements exist in dynamic tension—with platforms shaping content possibilities while content innovations drive platform evolution. As Marshall McLuhan famously observed, "the medium is the message," suggesting that the vehicle of communication fundamentally alters how we perceive and process information. This principle remains relevant as we navigate an increasingly fragmented media landscape characterised by both institutional and user-generated content. The Architecture of Mass M...

The Brown Sisters: A Four-Decade Portrait of Time and Sisterhood

 Nicholas Nixon's "The Brown Sisters" stands as one of photography's most compelling longitudinal portrait studies, documenting four decades of sisterhood through annual black-and-white photographs taken from 1975 to 2014. Using an 8×10 inch view camera, Nixon captured his wife Bebe and her three sisters—Heather, Mimi, and Laurie Brown—in the same order each year, creating a remarkable visual meditation on time, aging, and familial bonds. For the full set of images see the PDF below (for academic use only) Forty Portraits in Forty Years PDF What began as a spontaneous family photograph in 1975 evolved into a profound artistic documentation of human transformation. The project's strength lies in its methodological consistency: the sisters maintain their positions, with the sequence remaining unchanged throughout the series. This rigid framework paradoxically highlights the subtle changes that occur year by year, creating a powerful commentary on the passage of time...

A Critical Visual Analysis of Jan Banning's ‘Bureaucratics’

 Jan Banning's photographic series Bureaucratics offers a remarkable anthropological study of civil servants across eight countries, revealing how power, hierarchy, and cultural identity manifest in governmental spaces. Through meticulously composed photographs taken from a citizen's perspective, Banning unveils the theatre of bureaucracy the most immediate visual impact comes from Banning's consistent methodology: each photograph is taken from the same height and distance, positioning the viewer in the role of a citizen approaching the bureaucrat's desk. The bureaucrats are photographed in their natural habitat – their offices – which become stages where power dynamics and cultural values are performed daily. Make visual analysis of  Bureaucratics  by Jan Banning given below. Bureaucratics by Jan Banning PDF  (for academic use only) In examining the spatial arrangements, a clear pattern emerges: the desk serves as both barrier and symbol of authority. In many image...

Pope Francis—Fully Human and Fully Pope

 Pope Francis led the Church with the authority and obligation of a co-pilgrim. He became the conscience of the Church. Long before Pope Francis fell ill and the Catholic world began talking about what is next and who is next; while Pope Francis was still making waves of change in the Catholic and non-Catholic world, I heard men of the Church judging him, saying he needed to be a little more careful, tactful, and diplomatic; take time to speak and act—meaning to be conservative and moderate like the Church almost always has been. The pressure on Pope Francis was that he must restrain from saying things that would make him and the Church look weak, vulnerable, and human. I was of the opinion that the authority and influence of a Pope, the vicar of Jesus, who sits in a pompous cathedra is to be enduring even at the point of embracing vulnerabilities, and not run away; be comfortable with others and varied perspectives; face discomfort, sweat, anger; laugh at power; and 'have the smel...

Visual Analysis: INTRODUCTION

 Visual analysis is a systematic and scientific examination of visual materials that explores their communicative meaning, aesthetic qualities, and functional impact. As Susan Sontag noted, humans tend to linger in "mere images of the truth," making it crucial to develop a deeper understanding of visual interpretation. Study the PDF below (for academic use only) Introduction to Visual Analysis PDF The Nature of Seeing: The process of seeing is not as spontaneous or natural as commonly believed. According to John Berger, our way of seeing art has historically been influenced by privileged minorities to maintain social and economic dominance. Visual perception requires conscious effort and is heavily influenced by habits and conventions. The visual faculty consumes approximately two-third of a person’s used energy, highlighting its significance in human experience. The Framework of Visual Analysis: Visual analysis could be traced back to communication models, for example, Har...

Sigmund Freud on Creative Writing and Day-Dreaming

 Freud in his essay, Creative Writers and Day-Dreaming, explores the psychological origins of artistic creativity and the impact of literature on readers. He draws parallels between the imaginative activity of creative writers and the day-dreaming of ordinary people. It is a discussion about the relationship between creative art and unconscious phantasy. In it, Freud talks about the role of daydreaming and fantasy in human behaviour, and how creative writers are able to express their daydreams without shame or self-reproach. Read the essay below (for academic use only) Creative Writers and Day Dreaming PDF Freud argues that the child's play and the adult's phantasies/daydreams share a common element—the desire to alter an unsatisfactory reality and fulfil unfulfilled wishes. The creative writer is like a successful daydreamer who is able to transform their private fantasies into works that provide pleasure to the audience. Freud suggests that the writer's choice of subject...