Art: Further Debates

We have examined successive attempts to define Art: the representational theory, the expression theory, formalism, the aesthetic theories. All attempted to provide comprehensive definitions of all art, but each of them appears inadequate in some way to identify all and every art.

On the one hand, people grew familiar with arts of other cultures. On the other hand there have been the diverse creations of the avant-garde, which with their radical departures from conventional practice consistently challenged settled ideas of art.

Study the PDF below

(only for academic purposes)

Art: Further Debates PDF

Art is an Open Concept. Morris Weitz believed that the central error of preceding philosophers of art was that, by assuming that art could be defined, they treated art as a closed concept rather than as an open concept. It is an argument that any attempt to define/fix art must fail necessarily.

Morris Weitz’s Art as Open Concept argument. Art is expansive. Therefore, art must be open to the permanent possibility of radical change, expansion and novelty. If something is open to the permanent possibility of radical change, expansion and novelty, then it cannot be defined. Or, If art can be defined. Then, art is not open to the permanent possibility of radical change, expansion and novelty. Therefore, art is not art.

The method of Family Resemblances. The Neo-Wittgensteinians believed that art cannot be defined. The mistake was to attempt to define art essentially. They agreed that we need some way to identify art, but they thought the proper way to go about it is not to frame a definition of art and then to apply it to particular cases.

Following Wittgenstein, they thought the procedure that we should follow is what they called the method of family resemblances. Many of the concepts that we employ in everyday life largely go undefined: the concept of chair, the idea of games, etc.

Contemporary Theories of Art

1. The Institutional Theory of Art: Art is a social institution. Consult the relevant social practice on art –the art-world. Artist makes the art and art-world confers the status on it. The focus is on experts and practices.

2. Historical theory of Art: Some one should make/own it, and regard it as a work of art. Art goes through a chronological process.

3. Definition model to Narrative model: Look at the story of art-making. Identify narratives of a work of art coming into existence.

art, Art identification, what is art? art theories. contemporary debates on art

How to identify art?

Comments

Visual Analysis: SEMIOTICS

Visual analysis is a systematic and scientific approach to examining visual materials that goes far beyond casual observation. In our visually saturated world, images have become a inescapable universal language that shapes our perceptions, attitudes, and experiences. From the artworks adorning gallery walls to the advertisements lining city streets, visuals communicate narratives, evoke emotions, and reflect sociocultural ideologies. However, the process of seeing and interpreting visuals is not as spontaneous or natural as we often assume. As John Berger notably stated, "seeing is an active decision," suggesting that the process of interpreting visuals is neither spontaneous nor natural, but rather requires conscious effort and critical thinking. The way we perceive and interpret visual content is heavily influenced by habits, conventions, and our individual perspectives. Serious visual analyses requires conscious effort and critical analysis to unravel the layers of mea

Art Movements: Modern Art to Contemporary Art

There is no precise definition of the term Modern Art: it remains an elastic term, which can accommodate a variety of meanings. Art historically, Modern Art means works produced during the approximate period 1870-1970. A s per artistic style, traditions of the past have been thrown aside in a spirit of experimentation . A tendency away from the narrative (which was characteristic for the traditional arts). Inclination towards abstraction is characteristic of much modern art. Study the PDFs below (only for academic purpose) Art Movements: Modern Art to Contemporary Art Part I PDF Art Movements: Modern Art to Contemporary Art Part II PDF Impressionism Originated with a group of Paris-based artists whose independent exhibitions brought them to prominence. Eventually became the world's most famous painting movement. Paved the way for the wholly non-naturalist abstract art of the 20th century. Impressionism focused on the almost impossible task of capturing fleeting moments

Visual Analysis: VISUALS

Visuals are images/collection of images that are made to be seen. There is a continuum of images in which people live; and visual is a paused/frozen moment from them. Study the PDF below (for academic use only) Visuals PDF People/artists/designers capture/construct/make images/visuals for others to see. Therefore we only see the image/visual/frame that is given to us to see. For John Berger, a visual is a sight which has been recreated or reproduced ... which has been detached from the place and time in which it first made its appearance. Art: Traditional art, the oldest form of visual expression, represents humanity's first attempts to interpret and document the world. From prehistoric cave paintings to Renaissance masterpieces and contemporary installations, art has evolved beyond mere representation to become a vehicle for emotional, philosophical, and social commentary. Artists manipulate colour, form, texture, and space to create works that challenge perceptions and provok

Art Movements: From Renaissance to Realism

Prior to Renaissance there were more of art era than art movements. We arrive at renaissance after Byzantine and Medieval art. Study the PDFs below (only for educational purpose) Art Movements: Renaissance to Realism Part I Art Movements: Renaissance to Realism Part II Renaissance was the golden era of Classical Art. Between 1400 and 1600, Europe witnessed an astonishing revival of drawing, fine art painting, sculpture and architecture centered on Italy, which we now refer to as the Renaissance(French for 'rebirth'). There was gradual move from grand high art to art that is more human and down to earth. The major art movements were 1. Renaissance In very simple terms, the Italian Renaissance re-established Western art according to the principles of classical Greek art, especially Greek sculpture and painting, which remained unchallenged until Pablo Picasso and Cubism, broadly, modern art. 2. Mannerism Mannerists introduced tension and

Art as Representation

In different times and in different places and in different context Art critiques, thinkers have made efforts to understand the underlying essence of a piece of Art. Most were limited to their own times and philosophy of the world and human persons. Fortkochi, Kerala They were at finding ‘necessary conditions’ and ‘sufficient conditions’ for the truth of the statement that an item is an ‘art work’ . We go back to the first of such an attempt. It was the Greeks who first said, Art is Imitation of nature. And they broadened it saying, Art is Representation. Study the PDF below. (to be used for educational purposes only) Art as Representation PDF Most art we do and we encounter on a day today basis are all imitation of nature. Those who are able to do it best are the best artists. What makes them to be candidates for Art is the attribute of Verisimilitude they posses. More similar they are better they are appreciated. Nothing is an artwork, unless it is an imita

Visual Language, Elements, and Grammar

Visual communication plays a powerful role in shaping our understanding of the world. Like written and spoken language, visuals employ a complex grammar and system of meaning. Study the PDF below (for academic use only) Visual language, elements, and grammar PDF At its core, visual grammar is comprised of fundamental elements like line, shape, colour, texture, space, and typography. These are the basic building blocks that visual creators assemble and organise using principles like emphasis, contrast, composition, size, proportion, balance, and lighting. Just as words are assembled following the syntactical rules of language, visuals are constructed by purposefully arranging and relating these elemental units. Lines, for instance, can convey a range of associations through their orientation and qualities. Horizontal lines suggest stability and calm, verticals impart a sense of strength and authority, while diagonals imbue dynamism and movement. The weight and curvature of lines furthe

Art as Expression

For centuries, representation was taken to be the central, defining feature of art. The emphasis of Representation theories of art was on the outward aspects of things. In a loose sense of the word, art was primarily concerned with the objective features of the “ external ” world. By the mid 19 th century, artists began to turn inward ; they explored their own subjective experiences. Even while depicting landscapes (external realities) they attempted to register their reactions - the way they felt - about the landscapes. (they were not just mirroring nature) Artists were becoming more attentive to the subjective or “inner” world of experience . That gives birth to a new art theory, “Art as Expression”. Study the PDF below (to be used for educational purposes only) Art as Expression PDF Impressionism, though its an independent art movement, expressed more of the impressions of the passing moment and qualities of light as seen by subjective artists. We can see the beginning

photo.graph.art.design

Search This Blog